Features > Finance > Which Strategy is Best to Reduce Your Debt? > Page 1

theeverygirl_debtreducation

Which Strategy is Best to Reduce Your Debt?

Contributing Finance Editor:
Brittney Castro, CFP®

Ok, so you’ve come to terms with the debt you have, and you have some extra money in your cash flow to allocate toward extra debt payments. Now the question becomes: What debt-reduction strategy is actually best? There are a few debt-reduction strategies you can follow, but the Snowball and Avalanche methods are the most popular.

The Snowball Method:

This is what personal finance and debt-reduction guru Dave Ramsey preaches. With this strategy, you start by paying the minimum on all debts and allocate additional debt payments toward the debt with the lowest balance. This approach allows for immediate gratification and motivates you to keep paying off your debts. But because the debt with the lowest balance isn’t necessarily the one with the lowest interest rate, you might not save as much interest over time this way. However, since a lot of financial success comes from your behavior, this method produces some quick wins–which may help you stay motivated over the long haul. Also, since the cards with the lowest balances get knocked off first, this method lets you focus all of your extra cash on the bigger accounts.

The Avalanche Method:

Here, you allocate any additional debt payments to the debt with the highest interest rate (most likely a credit card), while paying the minimums on the rest. You continue chipping away at the most expensive debt until it’s completely paid off. Then you move to the next-highest interest rate debt and allocate any additional debt payments to it. Mathematically speaking, this strategy saves you the most money over time, since you pay the higher-interest debts before lower-interest ones. However, it may not allow for the immediate gratification of the Snowball Method.

So which is better? Well, I usually encourage clients to follow a combination of both methods. Start by paying off the debt with the lowest balance, then move on to the debts with the higher interest rates and continue to stick to the Avalanche Method from that point forward.

Here is an example:
Let’s say that you have a credit card with a balance of $900 and high 23% interest rate, $5,000 on an auto loan at 3.5% and $30,000 in student loans at 6%. You recently got a raise at work or extra freelance work this month, and have extra money to use toward making additional debt payments. Following either method, you can see that paying off the credit card first is the best decision as it has both the lowest balance and highest interest rate. From there, you can move on to making additional payments toward the student loan while paying the minimum on the car loan.

And of course, it’s best to work with a financial advisor who can help you design a strategy that is comfortable and efficient for you.

This post was contributed by Brittney Castro, CFP®, Founder and CEO of www.FinanciallyWiseWomen.com. Follow her on twitter @brittneycastro. Brittney Castro is not affiliated with TheEverygirl.com. Brittney A. Castro is a registered representative with and securities offered through LPL Financial, Member FINRA/SIPC. California Insurance License #0F33895. The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.

  • designRoundup

    Definitely the Avalanche Method…once you get rid of the high interest, you will be able to pay more on the ones with lower interest. 

    • http://twitter.com/Brittneycastro Brittney Castro,CFP®

       @designRoundup:disqus Yes, I like your thinking.

  • http://www.katskull.com Kat Skull

    The avalanche method is definitely the ideal way for me to attack my debt.  I’ve done that with one card, then I used the rest of my paycheck to pay off another card (which happens to be the smallest amount).  So, in a way, I’m using both methods at once.

    • http://twitter.com/Brittneycastro Brittney Castro,CFP®

       @katskull:disqus I like using the snowball strategy first to build momentum and then the avalanche method after that.  Let me know how it goes for you.

  • http://undertheoaksblog.wordpress.com/ Annie Zdroik

    This is the exact conversation my husband and I have been having lately. I hate to admit it but the Avalanche Method is definitely the best. I can see why with how much savings in interest, etc. but for me, I need to see the results. Luckily, our lowest balances also have to be paid off by a certain date to avoid the interest so we are making that happen by incorporating that in our monthly budget. Knowing those are about to be paid off is comforting and makes me feel OK about not seeing immediate results by using the Avalanche Method.

    • http://twitter.com/Brittneycastro Brittney Castro,CFP®

       @AnnieRoach:disqus Yes, having a game plan in place definitely keeps you motivated and puts your mind at ease.

  • Jay

    The avalanche Method is the one we go with at home. Instant gratification can wait! We’d rather have the most money-sucking ones paid off as soon as possible. 

  • http://laurenmaxwell.blogspot.com/ Lauren Maxwell

    Debt is so stressful. I tend to use snowball, for the gratification…

  • Christy

    The snowball gets me motivated to dig out of the avalanche!

  • http://snappycasualblog.com/ kelsey williams

    My husband and I paid off $39,772 of debt in 23 months using the snowball method. For us, it was the best motivation to pay off each loan as quickly as possible. If it was all about the math (interest), we would have been smart enough to see the problem in the first place and never got that far in the hole!

    • http://twitter.com/Brittneycastro Brittney Castro,CFP®

       @kelseywilliams:disqus CONGRATS!  this is huge and I agree that it is more than just numbers.  Finding the best approach is key and I am so proud at all your hard work!  Hope you celebrated!

  • Josie Morris

    Avalanche all the way!

  • http://twitter.com/wishandwhimsy Katie Adler

    I’m a Dave Ramsey girl! Build momentum.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AF766YQ7HZ3E3M4VPG4QFW4I44 Kathleen

    Snowball!! I tried the Avalanche first and then I regretted it. We were moving which naturaly took a couple months worth off my debt pay down strategy, and while I don’t use my credit cards anymore and haven’t for awhile, I paid just a little for a few months after that, because I guess it was just not that encouraging to feel like i paid a lot for a couple months and ‘got nowhere’.  So then i started with the card I could wipe out in 2 months and it made me feel good.  If I know i have just a few hundred bucks to go on something, success feels real and i am more apt to go without for a couple more months to keep going. 

    I agree the avalanche works for some people! I thought it would for me unit life kept interrupting my paydown plans (and thus my motivation). Getting rid of debt is done the same way creating it is – it’s a mix of money and psychological factors, where you’ve got to do what’s best for you to make the fewest mistakes!

  • Natasha

    I have actually used both methods at the same time… Wanted that instant gratification of paying off the balance on one cc, followed by moving a balance with a high interest to a 0% (for a small fee), and then paying off a third card. This is working like a charm, as I already feel accomplished in the fact that one of three balances have been eliminated :) Yeah!

  • Molly

    I personally agree with the snowball method for my situation – I have 2 credit cards with outstanding debt balances on them and one has a higher amount of debt than the other. For me it’s been extremely motivating watch the balance go disappear one before I deal with the other. It makes me feel like I’m getting somewhere vs spinning my wheels and it’s empowering. Its kinda of like I’m telling myself “OK, calm down let’s take one thing at a time” and its been working for me!

    I can’t speak to say having extra debt in student loans etc. however, if I had loans I maybe would have tackled things different. 

  • http://iheartgreatdesign.com/ ♥ Donna Vitan

    I’m in a better place financially now but when I had to go through a rough patch and amassed an incredible amount of debt, I was advised to take the avalanche method by a financial professional. So of course, I listened and god, it feels good to out of that hole. Other than that, I’m building more savings and budgeting within my means. This is definitely a tough lesson to learn.

  • http://www.debtconsolidationcare.com/User/good.nelly Nelly Brown

    I have read too many articles about debt snowball and debt avalanche methods. I have heard so many things about these 2 methods, that my mind has become totally numb. So, I’m shooting my question straightway.

    My friend has 7 credit cards. The interest rates are between 22 percent and 29 percent. Her total outstanding balance is $35,000. Should my friend opt for debt snowball method or debt avalanche? Which option will be better for her?

  • NosillaDraw

    I’m in a small amount of credit card debt but will soon be graduating into some student loan debt (which my parents have never expressed any information about my personal obligation to that). I would like to look into transferring my credit card debt into a lower interest account before I take on even more potential debt. Any suggestions?

Federated Media Publishing - Style