I may not have had to worry about pesky things like health insurance, taxes, or rent, but back in the 2010 golden age of dystopian, life just felt simpler. A more rational person might credit this to the sheer fact of childhood, but personally, I think we can thank The Hunger Games franchise. So, it’s safe to say that I was brimming with nostalgia sitting in the AMC, watching Haymitch, Snow, Plutarch, and more return to the big screen. But in the era of money-grab sequels, prequels, and reboots, does the Sunrise on the Reaping adaptation live up to the previous films? Fans of Sunrise on the Reaping, I have great news: We may have just been gifted the best Hunger Games film yet. Below, my full review.

What is Sunrise on the Reaping about?

Set 24 years before the original trilogy, Sunrise on the Reaping tells the story of Haymitch, Katniss and Peeta’s mentor, and his games. At 16, he’s forced to compete in the second Quarter Quell, where twice the number of tributes are reaped. We see how Haymitch, Beetee, Wiress, and Plutarch lay the seeds for the rebellion that unfolds in the trilogy, and how Snow’s cruelty shapes Haymitch into the struggling adult we know.

My review of Sunrise on the Reaping

I’ll admit, going into this movie, I knew I would, at the very least, enjoy seeing this world on screen again. Even if it didn’t hold a candle to the original films, stepping back into this twisted universe, especially as an adult who understands just how dark it is, was enough to get me in a theater seat. What I didn’t expect was for it to top my list as my favorite Hunger Games adaptation of all time.

If you’ve read Sunrise on the Reaping, you know that Haymitch has one of the most heartbreaking stories of any character affected by the Capitol. Once you know his backstory, the struggling man he is in the original trilogy is honestly a far better coping mechanism than I could muster. I worried some of that emotion would be lost on screen, since we don’t have such intimate access to the characters’ minds, but let’s just say I don’t know if there was a dry eye in the theater by the end of the film. Without diving into spoilers, we watch as Snow slowly chips away at Haymitch’s spirit when he’s only 16, until there’s nothing left for him but painful memories.

Joseph Zada’s performance was so emotional and authentic that you felt every knife to the heart like it was your own. Reading these books and watching these movies as a kid, I obviously knew the world was devastating, but with love triangles and rebellion plots, you don’t fully realize how insanely dark it is until you revisit The Hunger Games as an adult. Haymitch’s story, timed with the original YA audience entering adulthood, when they can truly grasp just how painful his life was and how integral he was to laying the original groundwork for the rebellion, made it even more impactful

“Whether you’ve been a Hunger Games fan since side braids were all the rage or you’re just looking for an entertaining watch over the weekend, Sunrise on the Reaping is definitely worth seeing in theaters.”

Not only was Zada’s portrayal incredible, but the casting throughout the film was also impressive. Every character stole the show when they were on screen, whether it was Kieran Culkin’s Caesar Flickerman, Ralph Fiennes’ President Snow, Jesse Plemons’ Plutarch Heavensbee, or Elle Fanning’s Effie Trinket. They embodied these characters we already know while still bringing a fresh perspective as we learned more through a new timeline and point of view.

Another aspect of this film that made it stand out from the other watches I love from the universe is how well suited the arena in Sunrise on the Reaping was for the big screen. The gorgeous landscape, with blooming flowers, vivid colors, and mountain ranges, was such an interesting setting to see play out in the film, especially as the beauty dissolves to show the killing machine that the Hunger Games‘ arena truly is.

That being said, there were obviously changes that had to be made to adapt the book to the screen. While the story feels truly tragic as a film, I might argue that it’s even darker and more depressing in the book. But I do think that the scenes that were cut didn’t take away from the plot as a whole. There were definitely moments that were made more palatable to appeal to a wider age range and avoid that R rating, but I still left the theater feeling thoroughly disturbed.

The one part of Sunrise on the Reaping that I was not a huge fan of was, surprisingly, the epilogue scene. It’s been rumored for months that Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson will return as Katniss and Peeta in Sunrise on the Reaping, and J.Law confirmed it recently on a Call Her Daddy episode. But honestly, I could’ve done without the entire scene. After such a serious film, it just felt cliché and cheesy for everything to be wrapped up so neatly with a bow. Yes, there’s a satisfying arc in reaffirming for the audience that Haymitch did live to see a birthday without a reaping, but we already know this going into the prequel. It felt a little Hallmark-y, and like I was watching three celebrities put on old costumes rather than seeing a return of their characters.

So, should you watch Sunrise on the Reaping?

Whether you’ve been a Hunger Games fan since side braids were all the rage or you’re just looking for an entertaining watch over the weekend, Sunrise on the Reaping is definitely worth seeing in theaters. The A-list cast alone stepping into these characters is reason enough, but even if you go in thinking you’re too tough to cry, I’d bet money you’ll prove yourself wrong. My apologies to Catching Fire, because Sunrise on the Reaping is now officially my favorite Hunger Games film.

lauren blue
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Lauren Blue, Editor & Book Club Co-Host

As an Editor for The Everygirl, Lauren ideates and writes content for every facet of our readers’ lives, from must-read books and behind-the-scenes interviews to beauty products she can’t live without. When she isn’t sitting in an AMC watching the latest buzzy release, she can be found scouring Goodreads for the perfect pick for The Everygirl Book Club. There, she co-hosts discussions with members, debating plotlines, fancasting characters, and, of course, tossing in her own recommendations.