Food & Drink

Everything You Could Possibly Need to Make the Best Fall Coffees at Home

written by JESSICA WELSH

The Everygirl’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

Source: Stocksy
Source: Stocksy

As much as I love treating myself to a cute little outing of walking to get my favorite Starbucks fall coffee drink or spending a few hours working at a cafe with a delicious latte, my wallet simply can’t handle making that a regular habit. Over the last year or so, I’ve become extremely passionate about making delicious coffee in the comfort of my own home, and let’s just say, my bank account thanks me every day.

I pretty much make myself a homemade iced latte with espresso made in my Nespresso machine year-round, but I like to use the fall months to really experiment and switch things up. Obviously, pumpkin and coffee go together just as well as Lorelai and Luke (get it, an extra coffee reference?), but you can really deck out your at-home barista station with so many things in the fall that you’ll forget about Starbucks altogether.

I’m all about romanticizing the mundane, everyday tasks that life throws at us, so why not start first thing in the morning by making your morning coffee your favorite ritual of the day? Here is everything you could possibly need to make the best fall coffees at home:


Your Coffee Maker of Choice

Making a delicious coffee at home starts with the machine you’re making it in. While we love a store-bought bottled cold brew as much as the next person, investing in a coffee maker you love is definitely worth it in the long run. Whether you need the convenience of a single-serve machine or crave the traditional taste of drip coffee, there’s a machine out there that will be a great fit for you.

Vertuo Coffee and Espresso Machine

Many of our editors absolutely swear by our Nespresso machines for the best barista-level coffee at home.

3 colors available

Shop now
Vertuo Next Premium Coffee and Espresso Maker

This smaller, thinner Nespresso is perfect for small spaces.

Shop now
K-Mini Single-Serve Coffee Maker

Not only is this K-Mini also great for small spaces, it comes in a few super cute color options.

5 colors available

Shop now
Single Serve Coffee, Latte & Cappuccino Maker

If you're loyal to your K-Cups but want to branch out, this Keurig with latte- and cappuccino-making capabilities might be perfect for you.

Shop now
12-Cup Coffee Maker

We can't forget about our traditional drip coffee lovers—this chic white machine will look great in your kitchen.

Shop now
French Press Coffee Maker

For those who want to make their coffee-making process a little bit fancier, a French Press will definitely help you do that.

6 colors available

Shop now


This quintessential fall recipe from Half Baked Harvest is the at-home coffee-meets-chai combo of our dreams.



I am fully aware that some people are very particular about their coffee and would never want to switch it up, but I strongly believe that fall is the perfect time to experiment with fun and festive flavors. There are so many great options out there for single-serve pod drinkers and traditional ground coffee drinkers alike.

Pumpkin Spice Light Roast Ground Coffee

Starbucks, fall, and pumpkin spice coffee are the ultimate trifecta... and you can bring that home with this ground coffee.

Shop now
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters
Pumpkin Spice K-Cup Pods

I tell everyone I know that these are hands down the best pumpkin K-Cups on the market.

Shop now
Bones Coffee
Jacked O Lantern Coffee

Looking to branch out from your usual brands? Try out this pumpkin spice blend from Bones Coffee.

Shop now
Barista Flavor Pack Coffee Pods

These barista flavor Nespresso pods will flawlessly compliment your favorite pumpkin creamer.

Shop now
Fall Blend Medium Roast Ground Coffee

If you want to be festive but don't love the pumpkin flavor, this Starbucks Fall Blend is your perfect match.

Shop now


A Milk Frother

It doesn’t matter if you’re an oat milk, almond milk, or dairy milk kind of girl. There is one thing I absolutely know: Frothing your milk and/or coffee creamer (pumpkin spice oat milk creamer, anyone?) changes the entire game. It is truly the key to achieving that coffee shop-level feel in the comfort of your own home.

Instant Pot
Milk Frother

This budget-friendly frother has a convenient handle and can make hot or cold foam.

Shop now
Original Milk Frother

This $16 milk frother is in all of our editors' kitchens.

10+ colors available

Shop now
Aeroccino4 Milk Frother

Interested in taking your coffee set-up to the next level? This Nespresso frother will help you do just that.

Shop now


This delicious PSL recipe from Ambitious Kitchen is a dairy-free and naturally sweetened version of a true classic.


Add-Ins and Accessories

Obviously, the key formula to a great cup of coffee is simply coffee and milk (or cream). However, I would make the argument that adding in a few little extras is what really makes the formula complete. You can choose a syrup, sauce, or topping that will make you simply forget about that $6 Pumpkin Cream Cold Brew. 

Jordan's Skinny Syrups
Sugar Free Skinny Syrups

These zero-calorie, zero-sugar flavored syrups are an ideal option if you're trying to stay health-conscious this fall.

Shop now
Syrup Variety Pack

Craving your go-to vanilla iced latte? Make it yourself with these flavor syrups.

Shop now
Etsy | Next Page Prints
Coffee Flavor Syrup Dispenser

Customize your labels to match your syrup collection!

Shop now
Gold Syrup Pump Set

These syrup pumps will have you feeling like a real barista in no time.

Shop now
Daily Drops

Adding Equilibria's CBD drops to your fall morning coffee is the perfect way to start your day off right.

Use code THEEVERYGIRL for 20% off your first order!

Shop now
Puremade Pumpkin Pie Sauce

This pumpkin sauce is all over TikTok—it's just what you need to drizzle around your iced coffee glass.

Shop now
Pumpkin Pie Spice

Starbucks tops all of our favorite pumpkin drinks with pumpkin spice, so take your at-home coffee to the next level by doing it too.

Shop now


This Eating Bird Food recipe details how to make your own pumpkin cold foam, so you can have a healthier version of the Starbucks fave right at home.


Mugs, Glasses, and Straws

Although it’s what’s on the inside that counts, what you drink your coffee in can add that lil’ something extra that makes enjoying your coffee so much more special. Pulling a festive, spooky-xseason mug or glass out of your cabinet is sure to put a smile on your face first thing in the morning.

Etsy | Charbonnet Shop
Spooky Season Iced Coffee Cup

Nothing will brighten your mornings more than this insanely cute "spooky season" glass.

Shop now
Hey Boo Mug

This $5 mug is the perfect subtle touch for your morning coffee.

Shop now
Amazon | HIWARE
8 Pack Reusable Glass Drinking Straws

Glass straws are great if you're looking for an option that is sturdy enough to stir and easy to clean.

Shop now
Etsy | The Groovy Coconut
Feelin’ Cute Kinda Spooky Iced Coffee Cup

The cheeky message and cute design on this glass makes it the iced coffee glass of our dreams.

Shop now
Amazon | Nightingale
Silicone Straws

These silicone straws in the perfect fall hues will fit right into your aesthetic Instagram story.

Shop now
Etsy | Love In Kyoto
Sanderson Sisters Mug

Do you watch Hocus Pocus multiple times per year? Then you need this Sanderson Sisters mug for your collection.

Shop now
Amazon | Libbey
Set of 4 Classic Can Tumblers

These editor- and reader-favorite tumbler glasses are not only great for your iced coffees in the fall, but they'll also be your go-to for the rest of the year.

Shop now
Etsy | NVDsignz
Ghost Iced Coffee Glass

This ghost-covered glass comes with a lid and glass, so you can take your iced coffee on the go.

Shop now