30+ Holiday Gifts We Love From Etsy

The Everygirl’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

Once upon a career, I owned a small Etsy shop selling homemade dollies. I remember feeling so excited every time I got an order and incredibly touched that my creations were making a difference in someone’s life. Every time I receive a product from an Etsy shop owner, it usually comes with a handwritten note and sincere gratitude. Plus, the handcrafted items are always so special and stay in my home for years. Win-win for everyone!

This year, I knew I’d do a lot of my holiday gift shopping on Etsy. There’s nothing better than supporting a small business, especially during such a tough time for owners. But Etsy is a huge space, and it takes time to sort through all the finds!

Luckily, we’ve curated our favorite Etsy gifts just for you. But purchase soon, because shipping delays are bound to be troublesome this year. Scroll down to shop our favorite items! 

etsy | PortraitsFactory

Custom Family Portrait

etsy | pavLOVEts

Custom Line Drawing

etsy | fromEdenlee

Custom Couple Portrait

etsy | GracePersonalized

Custom Letter Necklace

etsy | CaitlynMinimalist

Name Earrings

etsy | MilaMinimal

Minimalist Ring


Oval Signet Ring

etsy | BlackButterflySigns

Custom Doormat

etsy | shopHomeMaven

Custom Farm Doormat

etsy | NewJoyStudio

Monogram Apple Air Pods

etsy | theembarkingdogandco

Custom Pet Sweatshirt

etsy | TwoCorgisStudio

Hand Painted Dog Ornament

etsy | RiverryStudio

Watercolor Pet Portrait

etsy | JoyfulOrbit

Smiley Face Slippers

etsy | ShopSourLeaf

Astrology Tote Bag

etsy | WhoSaidThatShop

Custom Coaster

etsy | ShopHelloHarlot

RHONY Coloring Book

etsy | Shekrun

Pearl Headband

etsy | LumaAndCoShop

Glass Photosphere

etsy | sweetwaterdecor

Candle Care Kit

etsy | YourRoyalCloset

HRH Sweatshirt

etsy | letterfest

Custom House Sketch

etsy | OliviaMariePaperie

Custom House Ornament

etsy | wandersketch

Custom House Ornament

etsy | BananaChipStudio

Spotify Christmas Ornament

etsy | TailgateGamesCo

Yardzee Game

etsy | ItchingforEtching

30oz Yeti Any Sports Team

etsy | SpeakeasyIceMolds

College Football Ice Mold

etsy | SwankyBadger

Custom Barware Set

We Can’t Get Enough of These Black-Created Etsy Finds