I have a confession: I love Hallmark Holiday Movies. I have a Hallmark+ subscription, the Hallmark Movie Checklist app, and I can’t wait for the annual Countdown to Christmas. Sure, there are other great TV shows and movies from November through January, but nothing beats the comfort of a Hallmark classic.
I’ve been watching Hallmark holiday movies for as long as I can remember, and even though they crank out new ones every year, I find myself rewatching old favorites. When I see a promo for a movie featuring Tyler Hynes, Andrew Walker, Jonathan Bennett, Lacey Chabert, or Nikki DeLoach, I know I’m in for another iconic Hallmark film.
Are these movies “good”? Ask a movie critic, and they’ll likely say no. They’re packed with clichés, and they’re easy to mock on TikTok. But are they cozy, heartwarming, enjoyable, predictable, and complete with a happily ever after? Absolutely. In my opinion, that’s a greater measure of success than any critic’s review score.
Think of a Hallmark holiday movie as the cinematic version of a light-hearted holiday rom-com novel. Nobody grabs a seasonal rom-com expecting a literary masterpiece. We pick them up because we want to curl up under a cozy blanket with a mug of hot cocoa, get transported to a small town, and know that the couple will end up together and the holiday crisis will be neatly squared away.
Between hosting, shopping, and wrapping up the year at work, December is stressful enough. The last thing I need is a high-stakes drama. I want a town festival in jeopardy and a couple who saves it, then falls in love, obviously. A lot of people write off Hallmark movies because they’re “all the same.” I’d argue that’s actually the best thing about them. Here’s why.
You know exactly what to expect
When you sit down to watch a Hallmark holiday movie, you know exactly what you’re getting yourself into. These movies follow a carefully curated formula to bring the holiday romance magic to life, and honestly, there’s something comforting in that.
Here’s how it usually goes. The movie opens with a festive song, then pans over a cozy town or big city decked out for the season. Then, we’re introduced to our main characters. One is probably a successful executive, lawyer, or event planner who is at a crossroads in life. The other is a beloved small-town native who’s facing a major life decision of their own. For one reason or another, they’ll end up in the same place (usually the small town), and they’ll need to pull off some sort of holiday miracle together.
“When the real world is full of unknowns and twists, a simple story that is guaranteed to be tied up with a bow is a gift.”
It doesn’t matter which romance trope is powering the movie: friends to lovers, enemies to lovers, grumpy Grinch/seasonal sunshine, or second-chance romance. The chemistry and tension will build from the moment they first meet. They’ll go through the steps to save the holidays, and along the way, they’ll fall in love.
While you’re watching, you never have to wonder how the romance will play out, and that’s the point. When the real world is full of unknowns and twists, a simple story that is guaranteed to be tied up with a bow is a gift.
There’s always a happily ever after
Nearly every Hallmark holiday romance ends in a happily ever after. There are exceptions that lean more toward family, community, or healing, but the cliché romances are the ones I’m defending here.
When that familiar opening montage appears on screen, you know a happily ever after is coming in about two hours or less. There will be no lasting heartbreak (except for maybe a third-act breakup), and the movie won’t end on a cliff-hanger that makes you overthink the ending for a week. You’ll finish the film with the satisfaction of knowing two unlikely soulmates found each other and saved the entire holiday season in the process.
The holiday spirit is at an all-time high
If you need a little extra magic to get into the holiday spirit, a Hallmark movie will deliver. Everything from the music and outfits to the decor and even the holiday puns brings the spirit to an all-time high. Every scene and location looks like the holiday decor section of HomeGoods exploded, in the best possible way.
“They were never trying to be the best films of the year, and that’s part of what makes them so lovable.”
These movies usually revolve around a beloved holiday shop, café, baking competition, Christmas tree farm, iconic inn, or festive celebration. Then there’s the tight-knit community. You frequently see townspeople come together to support one another, whether it’s organizing a Christmas fair, reviving a local tradition, or simply baking cookies for their neighbors.
All to help our two leading characters save the season. There’s something extra wholesome about neighbors who go above and beyond for one another year-round, but especially during the holidays.
Hallmark is more inclusive than it used to be
Beyond the predictability, some criticisms call out Hallmark’s lack of diversity and outdated social norms. While the channel isn’t perfect, I believe it’s making progress in expanding its casting, subject matter, and inclusivity. The formula hasn’t changed, but the casts and stories are more diverse than ever.
In recent years, Hallmark has cast more actors across different races, religions, and sexualities, and incorporated that into the love stories. I love that they’ve focused on inclusion, so that more people can feel seen on screen during the holiday season and beyond.
Some of my personal favorites over recent years include Merry Memories, The Holiday Sitter (Hallmark’s first holiday movie with an LGBTQIA+ lead), Christmas on Cherry Lane, and Double Holiday, just to name a few.
Let the Hallmark movies be what they are
Hallmark holiday movies know exactly what they are. They were never trying to be the best films of the year, and that’s part of what makes them so lovable. They promise a snowy small town, a couple who falls in love, and a happy ending. And they deliver every time. There’s something reassuring about watching a movie where love wins, second chances are possible, and the whole town shows up to celebrate.
So this holiday season, make your favorite seasonal drink, gather your people (or enjoy a solo movie night), and press play. Whether you’re laughing at the tropes or genuinely invested in the story, you deserve a little cheer–no matter how predictable it is. Skip the guilt and enjoy the happily ever after.
Emily Wise, Contributing Writer
Emily is a Virginia-based content creator with over five years of experience creating content strategies for SaaS companies. Although she spends her days in the tech world, she has spent many years as a lifestyle writer for her personal site, as well as for several publications across the web.


