The status of my nail color always channels the vibe of my day—it’s just a statement of fact. And while OPI’s beloved Cajun Shrimp is my ride-or-die for summer vacations, and Lincoln Park After Dark will always have their spot in my fall nail polish itinerary, some of the best OPI nail polish shades are still quietly stealing the show, without many of us noticing. The underrated OPI nail polish colors that are just as glossy, just as long-lasting, and just as main character as Victoria Ratliff on vacation—but still remain remarkably overlooked. And while it’s tempting to hold onto this treasure chest of color shades like Lindsay Lohan’s skincare routine, there are no gatekeepers here!
So, if you’ve been grabbing that same bottle on repeat, season after season, consider this your nudge to mix up your manicure inspiration. These hidden gem OPI nail colors are perfect for when you want something a little unexpected but still effortlessly chic. Because every season kind of calls for a new kind of nail persona—and sometimes all it takes is a new OPI nail polish shade to revive it. Case in point: Band Tease is basically Gilmore Girls in a bottle, and Berlin There Done That is proof that seasonal transition neutrals can be way more unique than your bottle of Put It In Neutral.
Why these underrated OPI shades deserve your attention
This roundup of nail colors might resemble some of their more famous rival siblings—which is probably why they often get overlooked—but don’t let that fool you. Each shade still has its own kind of spunk, witty name, and staying power that makes it more than worthy of attention in your next coffee post on Instagram. This bold and vibrant mix is equally polished for work as it is fun for weekends, and matchable to whatever vibe you’re trying to bring to your function.
It’s also important to note that our team of editors takes pride in our signature OPI nail shades. I mean, just look at our lineup of beauty articles from the past year—we can’t help it. So, when we say we love a color, we really mean it.
The most underrated OPI nail polish colors:
1. Blinded by the Ring Light
Butter yellow was having its moment this year, and while I’ll admit yellow isn’t usually my go-to because I think it looks like I dipped my hand in one too many Lays bags, after trying this shade firsthand, it surprised me in its ability to be super wearable and versatile. It’s a perfect way to shake things up when you’re tired of reaching for neutrals, and want something with a little bit more pzazz.
2. Band Tease
I absolutely love the copper tones in this one. It’s the perfect fall color, elegant on any nail shape, and feels like a distant cousin to OPI’s popular Espresso Your Inner Self—but with that little extra something that lets it stand on its own. Honestly, it’s one of the most underrated OPI nail polishes on this list, and in my opinion, a must-try.
3. Hands In The Clouds
This shade is ideal for adding a little spunk to any occasion. It works just as effortlessly as fan-favorite OPI color, Alpine Snow, but with the bonus of being a bona fide conversation starter. It was born to be the spotlight, and is an OPI color worth trying out next time you book that salon appointment.
4. Raisin Your Voice
I’m a red nail polish girl through and through. Sure, Big Apple Red is a classic, but this shade is practically begging to be added to your rotation—just look at her. It’s dark enough to feel moody for the colder months, yet the subtle touch of glitter keeps it playful and perfect for summer nail season too. It’s consistently an overlooked OPI nail color in my eyes, but really shouldn’t be.
5. Berlin There Done That
Your favorite neutral shade should fear this taupe-colored underdog. It’s got all the sophistication of Barefoot in Barcelona, yet still remains an OPI nail polish color no one talks about enough. It definitely belongs on the top shelf of your bathroom cabinet, and is an OPI nail polish hidden gem that still stands the test of time, like its top-requested peers.
6. Full of Glambition
Sometimes a polish just looks so dreamy and good, you want to take a bite out of it—Full of Glambition is that girl for me. I already told you I’m a red girl at heart, so I couldn’t resist adding another shade to the list. Full of Glambition has just the right hint of orange that could easily compete with cult-favorite Cajun Shrimp, and compliments every skin tone well. It’s a must-try OPI nail polish if you want something close to home, but are also craving a little bit change.
7. Samoan Sand
OPI has no shortage of neutral shades, which is probably why some colors like this one often fly under the shelf compared to the top of it. It-girl chic in a bottle, this neutral shade is still my go-to whenever I want something timeless, and a little more unique than classic OPI nail polish shades like Put It in Neutral or Bubble Bath.
8. Leaf By Example
This shade is perfect for fall and holiday season, when the leaves are rustling and the festive bustle begins. It’s similar to Stay Off the Lawn!!, but to me, has a bit more of richer color profile that helps it stand out in the forest of OPI’s green hues.
9. Princess Rules!
I love the nostalgia this shade brings me—back to the days when glitter hairspray was part of my morning routine and sparkly phone cases were my whole personality. It feels like something I would have picked as a kid, which might explain my bias, but I also think it’s just as fun in adulthood when you want something delicate, bubblegum-y, and a little whimsical.
10. Amore at the Grand Canal
This is one to consider for your next European excursion or romantic getaway. It’s sleek, timeless, and feels like royalty at the edge of your finger tips. If you want something that can pair well with any vibe you have going on, Amore at the Grand Canal is your girl.
11. I Am What I Amethyst
Blues can be an intimidating color to wear for me, but I love the soft pastel in this retro lilac hue that changes from barely blue to barely purple depending on the light. It’s definitely an underrated pick compared to other OPI pastels. It’s especially great for those winter months when I’m feeling gloomy and want something to jazz things up.
12. Slip Dressed Up
I don’t know, this just feels like something Rachel Green would rock in her Ralph Lauren era. I love how universally flattering the shade is and how perfectly well it can complement any skin tone or vibe. It’s a must-try OPI nail polish color no one talks about, but now we’re gonna start.
13. The Pass is Always Greener
I can’t stop thinking about slime green being the color of fall, which naturally brings me back to this enchanting minty green shade. If Leaf By Example feels a little too loud for your liking, but you still want to lean into fall vibes, this trendy archived color is definitely worth swatch testing. It’s also role plays well as a cute mani-pedi pairing!
Madigan Will, Assistant Editor
As an Assistant Editor for The Everygirl, Madigan writes and edits content for every topic under the digital media sun. As the oldest of four siblings, she enjoys utilizing her big sister persona to connect and inspire readers—helping them discover new ways to maximize their everyday.
