Nail Ideas

7 Non-Cheesy Valentine’s Day Nail Colors To Try That Aren’t Pink


The Everygirl’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

Source: @gabrielegz
Source: @gabrielegz

Although I’m partial to a funky manicure every now and then, my nail vibe is typically pretty simple but with a twist. Check on me if I happen to show up with the same manicure twice in the same year. No matter how much I love my go-to O.P.I. “Mimosas for Mr. & Mrs.” shade, as soon as my usual two weeks are up, I’ll be back in the salon finding a new color to obsess over. When it comes to my beloved Valentine’s Day nails, finding a color I haven’t worn before is a challenge—but not impossible. 

If you find yourself wearing pink every single year and wanting to change it up, same. Below, we’ve compiled a handful of fun, out-of-the-box ideas to take your Valentine’s Day nails from “like” to “love.” 


1. Lilac

Any shade of purple will be unexpected but appropriate, but we’re loving a light lilac. It feels like a launch into spring after this cold tundra of a winter we’ve had.

Urban Outfitters
Nail Polish in "Purple Haze"
Shop now


2. Milky White

This creamy white will give a barely-there yet polished look to your nails—which will pair perfectly with feminine touches like pearl earrings for your Valentine’s Day date night look. And the best part? It’s so neutral, you won’t be itching to get rid of it after the holiday.

Nail Polish in "Marshmallow"
Shop now


3. Comme des Garçons’ Play Hearts

If you love cheeky V-Day details, this Comme des Garçons’ Play Hearts manicure is so playful and sweet. Start with a neutral base and add doe-eyed hearts on top in different sizes and placements.

Emilie Heathe
Nail Polish in "The Perfect Red"
Shop now


4. Metallic Purple

Metallic is one of the biggest trends in both beauty and fashion this year, and it’s no surprise it has made its way to nails too. Kick your purple mani up a notch by opting for a metallic shade or add a glaze on top for some shine.

Sally Hansen
Nail Polish in "Lavish Lilac"
Shop now


5. Heart Stickers 

This is just about the easiest design you can do, but the impact is major. When done with a neutral shade, the result is less cheese, more cute. We love this in white, but I’ve also seen it on IG in a deep brown shade—gorgeous

Olive & June
Heart Nail Stickers
Shop now


6. Raspberry

Just like the chocolate-covered raspberries you’ll buy yourself (or the wine you’ll drink), these scream Valentine’s Day in a less obvious way. Go a little lighter for a fuchsia tone or a little deeper for a red wine shade.

Nail Polish in "Rose Magenta"
Shop now


7. Neapolitan

This multi-colored mani reminds us of a box of chocolates with a pink bow, or better, the Neapolitan ice cream you will eat out of the half-gallon with your besties on Galentine’s Day.

Undressed Nail Set
Shop now


Nail Trends Come and Go, But These 9 Timeless Shades Will Never Go Out of Style